Seattle judges hear arguments on president's travel ban

On Monday a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Seattle heard Hawaii's lawsuit challenging the ban, which would suspend the nation's refugee program and temporarily bar new visas for citizens of Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen.

The Ninth Circuit panel is tasked with deciding whether to lift a court order, put in place by a lower federal judge in March, that blocks the Trump administration from implementing two key provisions in the revised executive order.

The judges on Monday did not indicate when they would issue their ruling in the case, which is expected to reach the Supreme Court.

The Trump administration says the temporary ban on refugees and travelers from six Muslim-majority countries - Iran, Syria, Sudan, Libya, Somalia and Yemen - is motivated by national security concerns, an area where U.S. presidents have wide powers.

Acting Solicitor General Jeffrey Wall, who represented the federal government at Monday's hearing, told the 9th Circuit that the Supreme Court has made it clear that all the executive branch needs to show is a "legitimate" and "bona fide" goal when deciding whom to exclude from the country.

Opponents - including the state of Hawaii and civil rights groups - have said that both Trump's first ban and later revised ban discriminate against Muslims.

That order was halted by a federal judge in Seattle.

Lawyers for the Trump administration have asked the 9th Circuit to permit enforcement of the presidential order, which the court is considering on an expedited schedule. It was the first federal appeals court ruling that determined gay marriage bans were unconstitutional. But he also said he hasn't read the text of Roosevelt's order.

This is the second time that the ninth circuit, which covers the western United States and is generally considered the most liberal of the appeals courts, has heard arguments over the travel ban.

One of the high points of Katyal's argument, in fact, was to use the setting of the Ninth Circuit hearing to link the Trump order to the infamous order by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during World War II to imprison tens of thousands of Americans - including citizens - of Japanese ancestry because of group suspicion of their loyalty.

The case before the 9th Circuit yesterday was filed by the state of Hawaii and Ismail Elshikh, a US citizen of Egyptian descent who serves as the head of a Hawaii mosque and is hoping to bring his mother-in-law, a Syrian national, to the United States.

Hamilton wins thrilling Spanish Grand Prix
In fact, Sebastian Vettel leaped off the line from second position to snatch the race lead heading into the first corner. He blocked me, in the end I managed to get past, but by then I had lost an very bad lot of time.

Katyal said Trump could formally disavow his earlier comments and say Islam was a peaceful religion, as did former President George W. Bush. As evidence, he rattled off an extensive list of amicus briefs submitted in favor of striking down Trump's order.

White House spokesman Sean Spicer told reporters on Monday that the administration was confident the executive order would be upheld by the appeals court.

Wall urged Gould to ignore campaign statements and focus instead on the wording of the revised order.

It is no less than outrageous this order is even being dragged through the courts. But the judge wondered whether Trump is forever forbidden from adopting an executive order along the lines of his travel ban.

"I want to be very clear about this", Wall said solemnly.

He said the rhetoric showed "significant and unrebutted evidence of religious animus".

Arguing that the United States needed to tighten national security measures, Trump's attempt to limit travel was one of his first major acts in office.

"This is a very limited, very unusual case when you have the public statements by the president".

Wall was formerly a law clerk for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and has argued before the nation's top court 11 times. Because of how the courts chose to proceed, a full slate of 13 judges heard the 4th Circuit arguments last week, while just three, all appointees of President Bill Clinton, will sit in Seattle. And then it takes that information and packages it as a temporary travel ban - a 90 day temporary travel ban - on people trying to come to America from those countries. "We fully believe that", Spicer said.

"No matter how the two courts rule, I predict this case will go to the Supreme Court", agreed Cornell Law School professor Stephen Yale-Loehr.

Recommended News

  • Lookin At Lee eyes Preakness glory after strong run in Derby

    Lookin At Lee eyes Preakness glory after strong run in Derby

    Although, I'm fairly confident connections wouldn't race him if he's not at 100 percent, but it may be something to watch out for. Despite overseeing a stable that runs in races nationwide, Pletcher is single-minded in his approach with each horse in his barn.

    Birthplace of grunge mourns 'Seattle's son' Chris Cornell

    He regrouped with Soundgarden three years later and maintained a steady flow of album releases and an global touring schedule. Fellow Seattleite Kurt Cobain was eventually the bigger star, the vanguard of a new cultural era that no one saw coming.
    President Trump to Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn (ret.),

    President Trump to Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn (ret.), "Stay Strong"

    But Flynn accepted, and many believe his new post as the senior national security adviser to President Trump, made him a target. Kislyak, Russia's ambassador to the United States. "He likes him, he trusted him, he was comfortable with him", he said...
  • Applications for US jobless aid fell to 3-month low of 232K

    Applications for US jobless aid fell to 3-month low of 232K

    Claims have now been below 300,000, a threshold associated with a healthy labor market, for 115 straight weeks. The Labor Department said Thursday claims for unemployment benefits fell 4,000 to 232,000.

    O&G stocks buoyant after Saudi, Russia agree to extend output cuts

    West Texas Intermediate crude June contract ticked up 27 cents, or around 0.6%, to $49.12 a barrel by 8:55AM ET (12:55GMT). Oil has surrendered about half its gains since the producers' accord to cut output late past year .
    O'Reilly: Ailes 'had my back' at Fox

    O'Reilly: Ailes 'had my back' at Fox

    Ailes went into politics when he started to advise President Richard Nixon on how to connect with television viewers. The report said a 77-year-old man - presumably Ailes - was reported to have fallen and hit his head at 1:49 p.m.
  • Kyle Lowry's Appearance Steals The Show During Toronto Raptors Loss

    It is likely they will get about a week off again until the Eastern Conference Finals begin. "It's going to be a long summer". Kyrie scored the Cavaliers next 11 points to give the Cavaliers a 103-95 lead and to give the Cavaliers some breathing room.
    Only one Spurs player shows up in Game 2 beatdown by Warriors

    Only one Spurs player shows up in Game 2 beatdown by Warriors

    And he'll probably get a lot more minutes down the stretch of this series, and he hopefully can continue to do the same". The veteran big man was working out on a stationary bike when the media was allowed into the team's practice facilty.
    New independent testing authority looks for clients

    New independent testing authority looks for clients

    The IOC, however, over-ruled WADA and handed the decision on Russian participation to individual sporting federations. It also announced the creation of a new independent testing body that would operate under Swiss jurisdiction.
  • Jose Mourinho vetoes open-training plans 'due to fears of tactics leak'

    Jose Mourinho vetoes open-training plans 'due to fears of tactics leak'

    In England, however, Mourinho said there had never been any concessions to clubs that go far in European competitions. I think the next time he plays will be against Los Angeles Galaxy during the preseason tour.
    Here's When 'Guardians of Galaxy 2' Happens in the MCU Timeline

    Here's When 'Guardians of Galaxy 2' Happens in the MCU Timeline

    Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 had a massive opening weekend, accumulating $425 million (Rs 2700 crore) worldwide. Disney, which acquired Marvel in 2009, spent about $200 million to make the visual effects-heavy "Guardians Vol. 2".

    Banks' cyber defences hold firm (for now)

    Digital Health News understands that NHS Wales also managed to avoid hospitals being hit by Friday's cyber security attacks. Its national incident director, Dr Anne Rainsberry, said: 'The message to patients is clear: the NHS is open for business.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.