McGovern: Judge's ruling finds Michelle Carter's words killed Conrad Roy

The prosecution asked for Carter's bail to be revoked, but Moniz allowed her to remain out on bail until her sentencing on August 3.

Three years ago, in July of 2014, Roy hooked up a hose to his truck that pumped carbon monoxide into the cab. Judge Lawrence Moniz is deliberating Carter's fate following a jury-waived trial that provided a disturbing look at teen depression and suicide.

"They know how sad you are and they know that you're doing this to be happy, and I think they will understand and accept it".

When 18-year-old Mr Roy had second thoughts, she sent him a message saying: "Just do it, babe". After she knew that he'd passed away, Carter did not tell his family that he'd killed himself, nor did she call police. "Get back in", Carter told Roy, according to a friend who testified Carter described the conversation in a text message to her about a month after Roy died. She was then convicted of involuntary manslaugher.

When Conrad expressed uncertainty, she said she felt "played" and promised to help his family through his death. Carter also allegedly texted Roy telling him to "get back in" to his auto prior to his death, after he reportedly texted her expressing hesitancy and worry. When he became sick because of the fumes, he stepped out of the truck, at which point Carter reportedly ordered him to "get back in". Prosecutors said, when he left the truck, Carter instructed him to "get back in", which eventually caused his death.

The court heard more than 20,000 text messages exchanges were made - with more than 1,000 of those messages sent in the days leading up to Roy's death.

YouTube/CBS Evening NewsThe court finds Michelle Carter guilty of involuntary manslaughter.

Woman is found guilty of involuntary manslaughter...

Macron's party set for big parliamentary win
But for him to be able to implement his reforms, he needs to be able to govern - and that means having a majority in Parliament. A second round of voting will be held on Sunday in almost all constituencies between the two or three top-placed contenders.

Michelle Carter, who was 17 when she committed the crime, was talking to her then-boyfriend via text during a suicide attempt.

He said that although the suicide was tragic, it was not a homicide.

"I don't think there is sufficient proof of causation", Bailey said yesterday.

Matthew Segal, the legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of MA, said that while Roy's death was a "terrible tragedy", it was "not a reason to stretch the boundaries of our criminal laws or abandon the protections of our constitution".

The judge said he did not take into account in his verdict Roys previous attempts at suicide. At no time did she tell him to seek help for his feelings about killing himself, but instead talked about the different ways to do it.

This case has been one to watch because it's uncharted territory that raises the question of whether someone could kill someone just through words and encouragement... and whether those words are constitutionally protected speech. Furthermore, Massachusetts - where the trial took place - is distinct from many other states because it doesn't have any laws preventing people from encouraging others to commit suicide.

CNN legal analyst Danny Cevallos said that the judge's verdict is concerning "because it reflects a judicial willingness to expand legal liability for another person's suicide, an act which by definition is a completely independent choice".

Recommended News

  • NHL: Looming expansion draft turns up trade chatter

    There was no way David Poile wasn't going to protect his top four defensemen , and this is the price the Preds have to pay. It doesn't make sense unless they have a deal in place with Vegas so they don't select a forward, such as Josh Bailey .

    Fleury among players exposed for Vegas NHL expansion draft

    The two-time reigning Stanley Cup champions are set to move forward with Matt Murray as their full-time No. 1 netminder. In exchange, McPhee was intent on stockpiling draft picks to help spur the franchise's growth through youth.
    Rout by Macron's party in French parliamentary election vote

    Rout by Macron's party in French parliamentary election vote

    Stepping down as its party chief, Jean-Christophe Cambadelis said: 'Tonight, the collapse of the Socialist Party is beyond doubt. Le Pen did have one minor victory, however: For the first time, she personally won a seat in the lower house of parliament.
  • Victims of Orlando Pulse nightclub shooting remembered at vigil

    Exactly one year ago, the city of Orlando experienced the horrors of the worst mass shooting in US history. Later Monday morning, hundreds of people dropped off flowers, drawings and cards at a memorial near Pulse.
    Senate approves sanctions bill to punish Russian Federation  for election meddling

    Senate approves sanctions bill to punish Russian Federation for election meddling

    The sanctions targeted Russian energy products as well as "mining, metals, shipping and railways and". The two senators who voted against the measure were Republicans Rand Paul (Ky.) and Mike Lee (Utah).

    Blues protect 11 players for upcoming Expansion Draft

    Along with Fleury, other goalies exposed are Florida's Roberto Luongo , Detroit's Petr Mrazek and Philadelphia's Michal Neuvirth . Each team had the option to protect either seven forwards , three defensemen , and a goalie , or eight skaters and a goalie .
  • Dreamers to stay, at least for now

    Dreamers to stay, at least for now

    Immigration restriction group NumbersUSA said it was "thrilled" that DAPA was rescinded, but wanted to see Trump continue to DACA. Homeland Security John Kelly formally revoked a policy memo that created the Deferred Action for Parents of Americans programme.

    Cosby prosecutor undeterred by mistrial, vows to try again

    Among the women who huddled with Constand was Victoria Valentino, who said Cosby assaulted her almost five decades ago. The Bill Cosby sexual assault trial was closely followed by the public, and by members of the legal profession.

    Xbox One X Formally Unveiled, Coming This Fall

    Furthermore, Xbox One X may be expensive now, but its price would go down as the cost of developing one drop over time. We will have been in the market for a year with PS4 Pro , and that thing also is selling faster than we can make them.
  • The Lakers wanted Markelle Fultz too. So now what?

    The Lakers wanted Markelle Fultz too. So now what?

    Perhaps, as one Philadelphia 76ers article said months ago, Karma steered Markelle Fultz to the Philadelphia 76ers all along. Embiid posted a photo on Saturday of he and Saric standing in front of a locker — already bearing Fultz's name.
    Ohio Amber Alert issued for missing 1-year-old girl

    Ohio Amber Alert issued for missing 1-year-old girl

    Officials said charges against Trent won't be determined until Monday morning by the Licking County Prosecutor's Office. The initial report said 1-year-old Keira Marie Trent was reportedly taken by her father, Matthew R.
    Nolan Arenado completes cycle with game-winning homer

    Nolan Arenado completes cycle with game-winning homer

    The entire crowd at Coors Field was hoping specifically for a cycle-completing home run and that's what Arenado gave them. Prior to Sunday, the last time the Giants gave up a cycle was to the Diamondbacks' Kelly Johnson on July 23, 2010.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.