Use-of-force expert: Minnesota officer justified in shooting

Jeronimo Yanez

Jeronimo Yanez

Prosecutors say he acted unreasonably in shooting Philando Castile during a July 6 traffic stop in a St. Paul suburb. Castile disclosed he was carrying a licensed handgun. Witnesses have testified that the gun was in a pocket of Castile's shorts when paramedics removed him from his vehicle.

Yanez's fate rests in the hands of a jury who will deliberate at the close of the trial.

Defense attorneys unsuccessfully tried to block one of two black jurors from the final group of 15 (12 jurors and 3 alternates), arguing a female immigrant from Ethiopia didn't understand the criminal justice system well enough to follow the proceedings.

Prosecutors are trying to raise doubts about a Minnesota officer's testimony at his trial in the manslaughter death of a black motorist.

Despite the disclosure, Yanez reacted by shooting him. "He didn't tell me where the (expletive) gun was", Yanez said, according to the Associated Press. He said that was significant because it would have meant Castile had the gun all the way out of his pocket when he was shot.

Other testimony Thursday focused on where other officers who responded to the shooting spotted Castile's gun after his body was removed from the auto.

During this interview, Dusterhoft says Yanez made several statements that are now inconsistent with his current testimony, including that he only saw Castile's gun barrel when Castile was reaching for an "object".

The instructor at the gun range in Ramsey where Castile took his permit-to-carry safety class also testified Thursday.

Yanez has said he was justified in stopping Castile's auto because he resembled a suspect in a convenience store robbery, according to court documents.

"I was able to see the firearm in Mr. Castile's hand, and that's when I engaged him", Yanez told the jury.

Instead of retreating to a safer position for himself, he added that Yanez remained at Castile's window so he could point down and to the left to avoid injury to the other passengers in the auto.

The defense's attempt to argue that only Yanez's training was relevant, not that of other officers, began to falter when Mangseth testified about St. Anthony's training and policies. "It's what officers across the country are trained to do in situations like this", Kapelsohn said.

PM: Details of agreement with DUP will be made public
Mr Coveney said a number of "core issues" still stand in the way of an agreement but he said he did not consider them "insurmountable".

Yanez is charged with manslaughter and reckless discharge of a firearm for killing Castile. After Castile told the officer he had the gun, Yanez told Castile, "OK, don't reach for it then", and, "Don't pull it out" - a response Kapelsohn described as "moderate".

Other key points made by Kapelsohn Friday morning related to the level of danger Yanez placed Castile's girlfriend and young child in when he opened fire into Castile's vehicle.

Police officer Jeronimo Yanez. After Castile told the officer he had the gun, Yanez told Castile, "OK, don't reach for it then", and, "Don't pull it out". He added it would be reasonable to assume Castile's plan was to fire the weapon. Dash cam footage caught audio of Castile telling the officer he wasn't pulling out the gun.

"The individual had a gun, (Yanez) didn't have time to (figure out) what his intention was", Dutton said.

Prosecutors have sought to show Yanez could have taken lesser steps, such as asking to see Castile's hands or asking where the gun was.

Kauser also said he never saw Castile's gun. "He'd be remiss in not doing so", Kapelsohn said.

Diamond Reynolds, the girlfriend of Philando Castile, live streamed the aftermath of the shooting on Facebook.

A Castile family spokeswoman after court Friday said they would have no comment until after the verdict. The 32-year-old cafeteria worker had a permit for the weapon. He rejected prosecutor Jeff Paulsen's assertion Friday that the central question in the case is whether Yanez saw Castile's gun.

Their analysis different greatly from an expert who testified on behalf of the state who found Yanez's use of force "unreasonable" and "excessive" based on a variety of factors.

Emanuel Kapelsohn was the second such expert in two days called by attorneys for Officer Jeronimo Yanez.

Philando Castile funeral was held on July 14, 2016 in St. Paul Minnesota.

Recommended News

  • Cleveland Cavaliers hoping to avoid being swept by Golden State Warriors: Crowquill

    Cleveland Cavaliers hoping to avoid being swept by Golden State Warriors: Crowquill

    For Cleveland , James came close to his second consecutive triple-double with 39 points, 11 rebounds and 9 assists. James also passed Sam Jones, Bill Russell and Baylor to move from seventh to fourth in career Finals scoring.
    Ireland's first gay prime minister Leo Varadkar formally elected

    Ireland's first gay prime minister Leo Varadkar formally elected

    Paying tribute to Mr Kenny, Mr Varadkar said: "I have no doubt, only for him, this country as we know it would not be here today". In 2015 , Varadkar said his sexuality, like his ethnicity, "is not something that defines me".

    Dems say they'll slow Senate work over secretive care bill

    A group of ten Republican Senators are secretly meeting and writing a plan to repeal and replace ObamaCare. The greater impact likely will be the interruption of the legislative process and routine Senate business.
  • Fakhar, Amir star as Pakistan stun India

    Fakhar, Amir star as Pakistan stun India

    According to Sportskeeda , Kohli said he was more than satisfied with Hardik Pandya's performance throughout the Champions Trophy. Harmanpreet Singh fired home the first goal for India with a double from Talwinder Singh taking the score to 3-0 at half time.
    Gunmen kill 2 navy men, wound 3 in Pakistan

    Gunmen kill 2 navy men, wound 3 in Pakistan

    Two terrorists killed: The Counter Terrorism Department (CTD) shot dead two suspected terrorists in Lahore on Monday. The Gwadar port and Baluchistan are an integral part of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor.

    Technology CEOs urged to join Trump initiative

    He also cited some examples of the current technology infrastructure, noting the use of floppy discs in Pentagon "legacy systems". The administration drew a mix of flattery and policy requests from the assembled technology leaders and university officials.
  • Pepe Tells Cristiano Ronaldo To Join Him At PSG

    A four-time Ballon d'Or victor , the 32-year-old Ronaldo is the top European soccer player. "I have not spoken with Cristiano. Ronaldo, 32, has just enjoyed one of his most successful seasons yet for Real Madrid .
    Putin, Saudi King Discuss Qatar Diplomatic Crisis

    Putin, Saudi King Discuss Qatar Diplomatic Crisis

    Qatar and Turkey also seek to engage Saudi Arabia's rival Iran despite differences with Tehran's policies in the broader region. While calling on Qatar and the Gulf nations to ease tensions, the United Nations said it is working to resolve the crises.
    Congress leader recommends Guinness Record for Shiv Sena for issuing most threats

    Congress leader recommends Guinness Record for Shiv Sena for issuing most threats

    The Sena's first preference was RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat .After Bhagwat ruled himself out, it pitched scientist MS Swaminathan. Speaking at an "opinion-makers meet" attended by with a select group of city residents from various sectors on Sunday, Mr.
  • Car Rams Police Vehicle, Explodes on Paris' Champs-Elysees

    Car Rams Police Vehicle, Explodes on Paris' Champs-Elysees

    A man could be seen lying on his stomach on the ground immediately after the incident, wearing a white shirt and dark shorts. Police tell The Associated Press that the suspect is from a suburb of Paris and had been "flagged for links to extremism".
    House Dems question Flynn disclosures of Middle East travel

    House Dems question Flynn disclosures of Middle East travel

    Three speakers' bureaus that worked with Flynn said they had not been involved in the trip, the two Democrats said. Flynn was also involved in talks "with [Egyptian President Abdel Fattah] el-Sissi's government", Cochran said.
    Russia Says It Will Track US Planes As Potential Targets In Syria

    Russia Says It Will Track US Planes As Potential Targets In Syria

    Moscow also called on the USA military to provide a full accounting of why it chose to shoot down the Syrian Su-22. An American F18 Super Hornet shot down the plane after it dropped bombs near US -backed forces near Raqqa , Syria.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.